★★★★★
"Nate, an excellent real estate agent."
★★★★★
"Working with Nate was an outstanding experience from start to finish. He was professional, very knowledgeable, responsive, and truly had our best interests in mind throughout the entire process. He took the time to answer all of our questions, was always available, kept us informed every step of the way, and made what could have been a stressful experience feel smooth and easy. His attention to detail, honesty, and dedication are unmatched. I highly recommend Nate to anyone looking to buy a home in the Keys."
★★★★★
★★★★★
"Nate was great and very easy to work with. Love our new place"
★★★★★
"The man is a "MACHINE " We interviewed 6 realtors and Nate stood far above the rest. He was understanding of our needs and issues ,very knowledgeable of the Keys market and above all honest. We were told the average time on the market was 90 to 120 days. Nate had us under contract in 30 days with 2 back up cash offers. Nate worked tirelessly for us and always kept us abreast of what was happening. If it were possible we would give Nate much more than 5 stars. Thank you Nate for all of your help and knowledge. You are most definitely the BEST real estate agent in Marathon.
Bill Nickel"
★★★★★
"Nate did an incredible job for us. He had our house under contract 30 days after he listed it. He worked diligently to bring us the "right" buyers for our property and we cannot say enough good things about him as a person. His ethics and determination to do what is best for his clients shines thorough from the moment you meet him and long past the closing of the property. I would highly recommend him to anyone looking to sell or buy in the Keys, he is the best!"
★★★★★
"Nate is one of the most talented and definitely the hardest working realtors in the Keys. Sharon and I could not have asked for a more from Nate. From listing to settlement in 3 months. Absolute pleasure to work with. Love his family also. Thanks so much!"
★★★★★
"Nate not only responded immediately when we were in search of a realtor to show us a property last minute while on vacation, he coordinated with the owners and got us a contract that day! He then sold our unit less than a month later. He was so nice to work with and I hope that we have more business to do with him in the future! He went above and beyond to make both of these sales seamless for us."
★★★★★
"Working with Nate in the Keys was a game changer. His knowledge goes far beyond buying and selling—he has a deep understanding of local laws, ordinances, zoning and water accessibility which is critical in a market like the Keys.
He didn’t just show me properties—he made sure I understood exactly what I was buying and how it would perform long term.
Most importantly, he genuinely cares about getting you into the right property. I couldn’t recommend him more highly."
★★★★★
"Nate knows the area well and made sure we found exactly what we were hoping for for a vacation home."
★★★★★
"Great local knowledge and work ethic!!"
★★★★★
""Nate Bartlett is an exceptional realtor who brings a wealth of local knowledge to the table. Beyond his real estate expertise, his experience with building and renovations in Marathon and Key Colony Beach provided us with insights we wouldn't have found elsewhere. He made a complex process feel manageable and transparent.
Nate is professional, patient, and incredibly knowledgeable about the nuances of waterfront properties and local regulations. We felt completely supported and never pressured. Highly recommended for anyone looking in the Keys!""
★★★★★
"We had an excellent experience working with Nate from start to finish. He was incredibly responsive, always quick to answer questions and keep us updated throughout the entire process. His knowledge and guidance made what could have been a stressful experience feel smooth and manageable.
What really stood out was his knowledge of the keys, how helpful and dedicated he was—not just in selling our home, but also in helping us find and purchase our new one. He truly went above and beyond on both sides of the transaction with videos, posts on social media and open houses.
We always felt like we were in good hands, and his professionalism and attention to detail gave us a lot of confidence every step of the way. I HIGHLY recommend him to anyone looking to buy or sell a home!"
★★★★★
"Nate did a fantastic job helping us find and purchase our vacation home in Key Colony Beach.. As out of state buyers, he did a great job explaining all the nuances to buying a property in the Florida keys. The process went smoothly with no surprises. He went above and beyond in so many ways. As out of state homebuyers, it was essential to have someone we trusted on the ground, managing all the issues that can come up, which he did perfectly. He was accessible and easy to communicate with. He even offered to take his own time to meet Comcast at the house for us for installation, saving us the travel expense. To say he exceeded our expectations is an understatement. He also referred us to a local mortgage specialist and an insurance agent who were both professional and easy to work with. Would highly recommend him to anyone looking to purchase in Marathon."
★★★★★
"We had an outstanding experience working with Nate Bartket when purchasing our home in Marathon, Florida. Nate did an AMAZING job from start to finish and truly went above and beyond throughout the entire process.
Not only did he guide us smoothly through the purchase and closing, but even two months after closing he’s still helping us get settled into the community — recommending great local restaurants, connecting us with reliable handymen, and helping coordinate items on our post-closing repair list. That level of follow-through and care is rare and speaks volumes about his professionalism and commitment to his clients.
If you’re looking for a knowledgeable, responsive, and genuinely helpful real estate agent in the Florida Keys, we highly recommend Nate. We’re incredibly grateful for everything he’s done for us."
★★★★★
"We have purchased and sold many homes over the years. We have worked with many realtors, but Nate has been the best. Nate is professional, friendly and very knowledgeable in the area. We never asked a question or had a concern that was not responded to immediately. We would recommend Nate highly. It was a pleasure working with Nate"
★★★★★
"We had an excellent experience working with Nate while searching for a short-term rental from out of state. His responsiveness and professionalism made a challenging process much easier for us. Nate is incredibly knowledgeable and pays great attention to detail, which helped us feel confident in our decisions. His dedication truly stood out, as he consistently went above and beyond to meet our needs. If you’re looking for someone to assist you in finding a rental, I highly recommend Nate!"
★★★★★
"Was great to work with and went above and beyond to help find me a place!"
★★★★★
"We had a great experience buying with Nate! With Lauren Price’s help (who’s great too and genuine) they were able to set up last minute showings as my husband and I were on a short timelines and needing to get housing to start our new jobs. Nate was patient with me throughout the process, always professional, and gave solid advice when I would ask for his opinion. It was a wonderful first introduction to the Keys and I would definitely recommend him if you’re looking for a realtor!"
★★★★★
"Nate was a pleasure to work with! He is a straight shooter and has awesome follow up skills (sometimes hard to find in the Keys in our experience) I strongly recommend that you contact Nate if you are buying, selling or renting your home in paradise!"
★★★★★
"Nate is a true professional and he truly strives to help educate his buyers along every step of the purchasing process! I've worked with Nate many times - his dedication, determination, drive and passion for real estate truly shine in every transaction!"
★★★★★
"Nate took the time to meet my budget and property needs. I can’t express how much I appreciated his knowledge in buying in this challenging market. He was quick to respond and get the deal done. I recommend Nate in representing anyone who is looking to making the keys their next home or investment."
★★★★★
"Working with Nate was an absolute pleasure from start to finish. From our very first conversation, it was clear that he was not only knowledgeable and professional but also genuinely committed to helping my husband and I buy a home in the Keys with confidence and ease.
As a Realtor myself, I have incredibly high standards when it comes to professionalism, communication, and industry knowledge — so trusting another agent with such an important transaction wasn’t something I took lightly.
Even as someone who does this for a living, it was refreshing to experience such a high level of service and attention to detail. Nate handled everything with integrity, professionalism, and a client-first attitude that I truly admire.
I wouldn’t hesitate for a second to refer clients, friends, or even handle future personal transactions with him. Truly a standout in our industry."
★★★★★
"I recently had the pleasure of working with Nate to assist a mutual client, and I was thoroughly impressed with his professionalism and dedication. From the start, Nate demonstrated excellent communication, attention to detail, and a true commitment to the client's best interests. As a loan officer, I greatly value collaborating with agents who prioritize a smooth, stress-free experience for our clients, and Nate exceeded expectations in every way. I look forward to working together again."
★★★★★
"After a year on the market with the wrong realtor, Nate came highly recommended as THE realtor to list with. His local knowledge and marketing strategies are TOP notch and hes an absolute pleasure to work with. My only mistake was not finding him sooner .THANKS NATE for the quick sale. Your professionalism and attention to detail is hard to find now adays and is very much appreciated."
★★★★★
"Working with Nate has been one of the best decisions we made in our journey to buy a home in the Florida Keys. From start to finish, he went above and beyond—answering every question, anticipating every detail, and making what could have been a stressful process feel smooth, informed, and even FUN.
Nate’s professionalism is top-tier, but what really sets him apart is his genuine heart. He didn’t just treat us like clients—he treated us like friends. And somewhere along the way, that’s exactly what happened. We started this process looking for a full time residence, and we ended it not only with the perfect Keys property to call home, but with someone we now call a true friend.
If you’re buying or selling in the Keys, you want Nate on your team. Hands down."
★★★★★
"We were extremely satisfied with our buying experience with Nate. He was professional and courteous at all times.He has a REEL knowledge of the area. My wife and I found our dream vacation home with his help. I would strongly recommend his services!"
★★★★★
"Working with Nathan Bartlett has been an exceptional experience. As a seasoned Realtor in the Florida Keys, Nathan brings an impressive depth of knowledge—not just in real estate negotiation, but also in the many trades and technical aspects involved in buying or selling property in this unique area.
What truly sets Nathan apart is his thorough understanding of the local processes and city procedures. Navigating regulations, permits, and inspections in the Florida Keys can be complex, but Nathan's expertise made everything feel seamless. He has a strong network of local professionals and tradespeople, which proved incredibly valuable during our transaction.
From start to finish, Nathan was professional, communicative, and genuinely invested in achieving the best outcome. Whether you're buying, selling, or investing, I highly recommend Nathan Bartlett for anyone looking for a knowledgeable, hands-on, and reliable real estate partner in the Florida Keys."
★★★★★
"I had a listing opportunity down in the Florida Keys, which I could have broker by myself as a Florida broker however, I wanted to partner with somebody who was really close to the listing and I chose to work with Nate. Nate was amazing best realtor best agent in Marathon Florida. If you need a property in the Florida Keys or you have a property to sell, you need to call Nate. He was aggressive. He was smart. He was on his game and he did it all with poise and a smile. Nate and I will definitely be working together again."
★★★★★
"Nate was first class to work with start to finish! Highly recommend."
★★★★★
"Awesome at his job! I did not know any realtors in the Keys. I was reluctant to commit to anyone there until I met them in person. It took five minutes with Nate and I knew he was my guy for buying real estate in the Keys. He was so knowledgeable and went far out of his way to help, regardless of the benefit or lack of benefit to himself personally. I would highly recommend using Nate for anyone looking to buy or sell real estate in the Keys."
★★★★★
"Nate was referred to us by a neighbor and we are extremely lucky to have taken our neighbor's advice. Nate did a wonderful job in all aspects of marketing and selling our home. He was deeply committed to the project to the point of our wondering if he had time for other properties since he took so much time working ours. He was always available to us for any reason. From guiding us to readying the house for showing to walking us through the closing process, and everything in between, he was always there with professional and caring advice. We've sold a few houses, but we never received the attention and high quality service that we received from Nate."
★★★★★
"Working with Nate was an absolute pleasure! His expertise, professionalism, and dedication made both buying and selling a seamless, stress-free experience. From start to finish, he provided outstanding guidance and communication, always going above and beyond to ensure we not only found the perfect property but also sold ours quickly and for top market value. His in-depth knowledge of the Florida Keys market, particularly waterfront and investment properties, was truly invaluable. We couldn’t be happier with the results and highly recommend Nate to anyone looking for a top-tier real estate professional in the Florida Keys!"
★★★★★
"We met Nate while we were browsing open houses. We didn't have a Realtor, not being especially serious about the buying process, so we were unbelievably lucky to find Nate. He was the Realtor for a house we fell in love with, and since then he's just been an absolute gem. He's professional and friendly (often we find that people fall too far on either side of that line, so we love finding someone with a great balance).
Nate is plugged into the scene here in the keys. We've asked him for dozens of recommendations, and he's always got one... and they're always good!
Nate is responsive and patient and has made buying this house downright easy. We can't recommend him enough!"
★★★★★
"I am pleased to work with Mr Nate Bartlett for listing and selling my property in Marathon in the Florida Keys. He did a lot more than usual easy transaction but worked so hard taking care all the obstacles using his own time to clear one by one with care and fast pace. Also he is great communicator responding questions fast. I will suggest that anyone who is interested in looking for a realtor in Florida specifically in the keys I give him highest stars I can give. Thank you so much for all your help and support. Kei O"
★★★★★
"Nate was amazing to work with in selling our vacation home. He was able to coordinate services when we needed assistance, found reliable buyers and maintained a positive attitude in everything throughout the process. His smile and guidance made the struggle of selling a property a pleasure. Thank you, Nate, for all you did for a quick sale and transition to the new owners."
★★★★★
"What a great experience we had selling our home with Nate. The knowledge he had with the market was amazing. From the very beginning he was personally involved with every step, from the first pictures to the final inspection, he was on site. He dealt with the buyers on a regular basis to make sure everything was moving along smoothly. We couldn’t ask for a better agent. Thanks Nate!"
★★★★★
"Excellent service. Nate made himself available and was very patient during the buying process."
★★★★★
"We had an incredible experience working with Nate as our Realtor to sell our home in Marathon. Since we were out of state mostly, we heavily relied on Nate to assist us not only in selling the property but also with various other tasks along the way to ensure a smooth and successful sale. Nate has consistently been a pleasure to work with, always being readily available and friendly. Given his extensive knowledge of the real estate business, we had complete confidence in his expertise. We want to express our sincere gratitude to Nate for successfully selling our home and we highly recommend him to anyone looking to buy or sell in the beautiful Florida Keys!"
★★★★★
"Nate Bartlett with Island Breeze Realty made my house purchase in Marathon as simple and efficient as any real estate transaction I have ever done.
He has a team of very experienced people that are there to help. The team he put together for me included the appraiser, the mortgage company, the insurance company, and even a handyman that did minor repairs that he thought was necessary for an excellent transition before I took possession of the home.
Furthermore, once I was fully moved in, I had some questions about the boat dock and he happily came over to help. Who does that!
In conclusion, if you are looking for a realtor that is professional, efficient, and helpful, call Nate. I would not consider anyone else."